Letter to the Editor - Merron: No vote in the decision? But who bears the consequences?

It is staggering to me that one proposed 500-megawatt hyperscale data center, operating at full capacity, could use nearly as much electricity in one day as all South Dakota households combined! How might that affect our future electric bills and the electrical capacity needed for new homes, businesses, and future employers?

The proposed Gemini data center near Brandon, on land annexed into Sioux Falls, raises serious questions for me.

Having lived in this growing community for many years, I care about its future. The more I learn about concerns surrounding hyperscale data centers across the country, and the more Sioux Falls City Council meetings I attend, the more concerned—and frustrated—I become.

I strongly disagree with leaving local governments to regulate multibillion-dollar corporations when some of the people living closest to these developments have no say in the decisions. The sky, air, and water do not follow municipal lines!

What about diesel-generator emissions, constant industrial noise, loss of our beautiful night skies, and construction traffic? With prevailing winds often coming from the west, shouldn’t potential air-quality impacts be studied? What about the enormous heat generated and demands on emergency responders?

These are questions, not accusations against Gemini. But shouldn’t independent studies examine the environmental and health impacts, establish whether this enormous electrical capacity is actually needed, and determine whether safer, more appropriate locations exist?

I am also troubled by nondisclosure agreements and land transactions that leave citizens learning about enormous hyperscale data centers only after important decisions have been made. Existing regulations were not designed for projects of this magnitude. That’s why Sioux Falls now has a Regulatory Oversight Committee working to develop appropriate safeguards.

A developer’s preferred location should not automatically become the community’s responsibility to accommodate. Companies expecting enormous profits can afford to foot the bill for the infrastructure their projects require, even if it takes more time.

I believe our 2027 South Dakota Legislature should consider minimum statewide standards addressing locations, transparency, independent studies, and protections for neighboring communities. Federal standards deserve consideration as well.

I am not opposed to technology or economic growth. But I believe in responsible economic development. Progress should be measured not only by dollars invested, but by what it protects, what it costs, and what it leaves behind. Our air, sky, and water are not luxuries; they are necessities!

We may not have had a vote, but we still have a voice.

Make your voice heard before Nov. 27! Submit your concerns and proposed safeguards to the Sioux Falls Regulatory Oversight Committee.

Submit comments to the Oversight Committee:    

Learn more: www.letsiouxfallsvote.com     

Cindy Merron

Brandon Valley School District 49-2 resident

Category:

The Brandon Valley Journal

 

The Brandon Valley Journal
1404 E. Cedar St.
Brandon, SD 57005
(605) 582-9999

Email Us

Facebook X

Please Login for Premium Content