Editorial: Does big-box store development detract from small-town feel?

In recent weeks a Sioux Falls developer announced plans to develop empty land at Brandon’s I-90 exit. Possibilities, he said, include a grocery store, movie theater, restaurants and a big box store. 

This is good news for Brandon’s economic front with guaranteed tax revenue for the city. It also means more convenience for residents looking for nearby shopping, dining and entertainment options. 

The proposed development would not only save this town of roughly 10,000 from making the six-mile trek to catch a flick on the big screen, but it could also potentially give residents a second option as to where they want to buy their groceries should the developer succeed in securing a second supermarket. 

But one thing many Brandon residents have stated they appreciate about their community is its small-town feel. Some have said this element is one of the reasons they live here, second only to the high-quality school district in priority. 

And it’s true that Brandon offers much of what neighboring Sioux Falls does, while retaining its own identity and that small-town feel.

What gives a city a small-town feel?

It’s running into your handyman in the grocery store and having him ask about your washer. 

Ordering coffee in the drive-through and finding out the person in front of you paid for it. 

Getting a phone call from a stranger who tracked you down to tell you your package was mistakenly delivered to them.  

Getting pulled over by an officer for having an expired tag and being let go with just a warning, because it’s the holidays, and he trusts you’ll to take care of it. 

Sending your car to the local mom-and-pop for repairs and trusting them to do a solid job. 

Having one high school.

It’s familiarity, kindness and trust, and Brandon has all of that.

While a sprawling retail development with big-city amenities like a big box store, movie theater and chain grocery store would certainly boost Brandon’s tax revenue, bring employment and please many residents, would it detract from that small-town feel? 

When a community gains options, does it start to lose that sense of familiarity and charm? 

Or do options simply enhance the community?

Only time will tell.